Score every board software demo on the same ten criteria.
A vendor-neutral evaluation framework for boards comparing HOA platforms, project tools, and “all-in-one” suites — so you buy on a scorecard you can defend, not a logo preference.
Get the free guide
Enter your email and we'll send the PDF instantly.
Built for HOA, condo, and co-op boards comparing two to four tools this quarter
The problem: most software comparisons fall apart at the board vote
Boards rarely lack options — they lack a consistent way to compare them. Without one framework applied to every demo, the “winner” is a vibe, not a defensible decision.
Comparing tools that do different jobs
Dues platforms, project-record tools, and shared drives get lined up as if they were substitutes. “We already have HOA software” and “that one also has a documents folder” never tell you whether a roof job survives turnover.
Scoring the homepage, not the demo
A logo preference, a slick AI feature, or the loudest salesperson wins — instead of what you actually saw the product do. Later vendors then blur the answers the first vendor gave.
A comparison that will not survive the vote
When the board decides, there is no shared scorecard to point to — and when an owner, auditor, or attorney later asks how the tool was chosen, there is nothing in the minutes to defend the decision.
What's inside
A framework you can use on any vendor — score what you actually saw in the demo, not what the homepage promised.
Two categories, not one HOA stack
Why resident/community management (dues, portals, violations) and project governance (vendor email, bids, approvals, audit trail) are different jobs — and why many boards should keep both.
A 10-criterion scoring matrix
Score every product 1–5 on email integration, vendor experience, document handling, board continuity, approvals, audit trail, AI/search, payments, data ownership, and security.
Ten questions for any demo
The exact questions to ask each vendor, in order — starting with “a vendor emails a bid tonight; what does the board see in the morning with no one uploading anything?”
Six red flags that predict failure
Portal-dependent email capture, a pile of files with no timeline, records that vanish at cancel, no real export, silently editable history, and “AI” that cannot cite a page.
A printable, board-ready scorecard
Score up to three products before the vote and attach the card to the minutes — so the record shows the criteria, not just the vendor name.
How to weight and decide
Do not just add the scores. Decide from the high-weight rows that match your next twelve months — and recognize when the honest answer is a stack, not a single winner.
Ready to score your next demo?
Get the free buyer's guide delivered to your inbox in seconds.